Testing Methodology
Every headphone included in this guide underwent comprehensive hands-on testing by our editorial team. We focused on several key factors to determine what constitutes high-quality noise-cancelling headphones:
-
Active Noise Cancellation Performance: This feature was critically assessed during both indoor and outdoor usage. We tested headphones while engaging in typical activities, including conversations, exposure to loud external sounds, and day-to-day work tasks to evaluate their effectiveness.
-
Comfort: Recognizing that comfort can vary significantly among users, we evaluated the adjustability of each headphone model to cater to different ear and head sizes, taking into account both earbud options and headband adjustments.
-
Audio Quality: We listened to a diverse range of music genres and podcasts, examining how well each headphone performed across different audio settings. Where applicable, we tested various equalizer presets to see their impact on sound performance.
-
Battery Life: We closely monitored battery consumption during testing to ensure that performance matched the manufacturer’s claims regarding battery longevity.
-
Value: We analyzed features in relation to price points, comparing headphones to determine overall worth. For example, while the Bose QC Ultra offers exceptional comfort, it may not be the best choice for those prioritizing sound quality over comfort.
-
Premium Features: We assessed additional functionalities offered by each headphone, such as spatial audio and customizable equalizers. While these features contributed to overall value, they were not prioritized over essential performance metrics.
Our recommendations are based on thorough reviews and dedicated hands-on testing specifically for this buying guide. Models such as the AirPods Max were excluded due to their inferior feature-to-price ratio compared to more recent offerings from notable brands.
Recent Testing Updates
As of January 2024, we have removed the Bowers & Wilkins PX7 headphones from our recommendations. Although they are still high-quality headphones, their age and limited availability influenced this decision. We have tested their successor, the Bowers & Wilkins Px7 S2e, which impressed us in terms of sound quality and build but fell short in active noise cancellation and multipoint pairing features.
In April 2024, we added the Anker Soundcore Life P3i, Sony WF-1000XM5, and Sony ULT Wear headphones to our lineup. We also evaluated the JBL Tour One M2, which offered excellent multipoint pairing and battery life but did not measure up in noise cancellation when compared with similarly priced alternatives.
By August 2024, we formally removed the Bose 700 headphones from our best noise-cancelling recommendations as they were discontinued following the launch of the Bose QC Ultra headphones. We are actively seeking new models that provide adjustable noise cancellation features.
We also tested the Denon PerL Buds Pro, but found their exceptional sound quality was overshadowed by discomfort during wear and their premium price point.
In late August and September 2024, we evaluated the new JBL Live Beam 3 headphones, noting their engaging sound quality and innovative design, specifically the touchscreen case. However, their noise cancellation capabilities did not justify the $200 price tag. Additionally, we introduced the Dyson OnTrac headphones, which stand out for their impressive 55-hour battery life.
Looking Ahead
We are currently assessing whether the AirPods 4 could serve as a strong choice for mid-range headphones, particularly given their recent inclusion of active noise cancellation at a price point of $179. Stay tuned for our comprehensive review of the new AirPods.
